Official rates Key rate 14%
Russia Economy

guideMarkets

Clean-price or total-return bond index: how to compare like with like

Start with the same bond basket, dates and currency, then check how coupons are treated. A price decline and a positive holding-period return can coexist without a contradiction.

Two metal trays with blue cards, one also holding silver discs
Two metal trays with blue cards, one also holding silver discs Russia Economy

To compare two bond-index performance figures, first match the basket, currency and observation dates. Then read the return definition. A clean-price index follows prices without accrued coupon interest; a total-return index also accounts for coupon income under its stated reinvestment rules.

Moscow Exchange describes this distinction in its bond-index framework. Its indices are calculated using both clean-price and total-return approaches. The latter reflects changes in bond value and accrued coupon income, assuming coupon payments are reinvested. That extra income component can change the direction of a comparison.

Price and income answer different questions

A clean-price series helps isolate changes in quoted bond prices. It does not represent all the cash and value a holder receives over a period.

Accrued interest is the interest accumulated since the relevant coupon date but not yet paid. It is excluded from the clean price. A total-return methodology tracks more than that quotation, incorporating income according to the provider’s rules.

This does not make one series inherently better. A question about price movements calls for a price measure; a question about the performance of a basket including income calls for a total-return measure. The mistake is using one while describing the other.

A deliberately simple example

Suppose a hypothetical bond is worth 1,000 rubles at the start and 990 rubles at the end of a holding period. During that period it pays a 40-ruble coupon.

Assume accrued interest is zero at both endpoints, there are no fees or taxes, and the coupon earns no additional return within the period. These assumptions isolate the arithmetic; they are not a description of an actual MOEX security or its daily index formula.

The price change is (990 − 1,000) / 1,000, or −1%. Including the coupon, the simplified holding-period return is (990 + 40 − 1,000) / 1,000, or +3%.

Both results can be correct. They count different things. The 3% is a return over the example’s holding period, not an annual yield or a forecast. A real total-return index applies its own timing, reinvestment and constituent-weight rules.

Index points are not an interest rate

An index level of 150 does not mean a 150% yield. Index levels use a chosen starting scale. To measure the change between two observations of the same series, divide the later level by the earlier one and subtract one.

For example, a rise from 100 to 103 represents 3% over that interval. Comparing the raw level of one index with another that started on a different date or scale tells little about relative performance. Rebasing both series to 100 can make a chart readable, but cannot make different bond baskets equivalent.

Match the exposure before interpreting the gap

Check the issuer group, rating range, duration band and currency as well as the return label. A corporate-bond basket and a government-bond basket differ in more than their treatment of coupons. Constituents can also change at scheduled reviews.

Use matching observation dates and note gaps or paused calculations. Filling a missing observation with zero manufactures a loss; silently repeating the last value can conceal that the series stopped updating.

Keep the benchmark separate from the investor

A published index result is not automatically a fund’s result or a person’s realized return. Fees, taxes, trading prices, cash-flow dates and the ability to reproduce the basket can create differences. A reinvestment assumption is part of a calculation, not a guarantee that every holder reinvests on identical terms.

Before using a comparison, record six items: the exact index identifiers, basket definitions, currency, start and end dates, coupon treatment, and any methodology changes or missing values. With those in place, the gap between two lines becomes something that can be explained rather than merely noticed.